I was invited to give a talk earlier this week to Leeds University students who are thinking of creative writing careers. I really must force myself to go by notes next time as I find I get more and more nervous as time goes on and forget the good points I thought of saying when I imagined doing the talk. There were two questions I wanted to add more to but didn't, so here goes my ten pence on them.
One person said that her tutors had said 'it's all in the rewriting' - did I agree? Yes and no, I said. I've started to get wary of rewriting. Do I think work needs editing - hell, yes. You can't beat help from a good editor. The rewriting I'm wary of isn't the kind where you fix what doesn't work, prune the deadwood and all that. I'm wary of rewriting that shuffles the deck chairs on the Titanic - because I've done a lot of that in my life on old projects that needed chucking away and starting again. I'm wary of rewriting that fusses and fizzes, changing things into different stuff that's really the same as it was before, just different.
Both of these kinds of rewriting are a waste of time that serves the same purpose as writer's block but without the horrible blank page - it prevents you having to face any of the following facts: that you have finished and must send out your work to someone else, that you have done all you can do and it still isn't going to fly, that you need to start something new, that you are pretending to work so you can fool other people you aren't wasting your time. There's also the rewriting that you might do because someone in authority (well, you have to decide who that might be, an agent perhaps or an editor you want to get friendly with) has suggested it might be a good idea for the market or somesuch, and you go ahead and struggle on with it even though your heart feels like it's sinking in mud. Then there's the rewrites you do because a tutor says it's all in the rewrites and so you have to rewrite because that's how the process works.
I'd be very wary of any proclamations like the last one and any advice that makes your spirits plunge into sludge. I should say however, there's two kinds of sludge. There's the sludge of This Just Isn't What I'm About and there's the sludge of You're Right, There's Work To Be Done. If the first, do not rewrite, find another audience. If the second, you'll have to decide on a plan of works. You can always mistake No2 Sludge for No1 Sludge if you have a big, fragile ego, or are heroically lazy, so be careful there.
Writer's Block was the other topic I rather fudged. Someone asked what I thought about it. I said, and I still think, you have it if you can afford to have it but I didn't really elaborate. It's kind of performance anxiety, I think, and has nothing to do with what people say about it, such as 'I have no ideas. I can't think of what to write.' These may be true, as experiences, but they're sitting on top of the real issue, because ideas are ten a penny and thinking of what to write is just having ideas. Having ideas is natural to people, as much as breathing. Writer's Block is more like a suppression of the ideas as they come up, usually because they're 'not good enough'. There are all kinds of reasons why one might think this, many ideas aren't good enough after all, but some of them surely are worth a try. But mostly writer's block is simply a stalling action as the name suggests, there to prevent anything 'bad' occurring to the writer, and for 'bad' we can always read rejection of one form or another.
I am very poor at dealing with rejection but while I've got slowly better at that over time I've managed to avoid writer's block at many points simply by dropping all pretence at 'standards' and giving myself permission to write utter garbage for as long as it takes. With the pressure off, everything proceeds normally. Since I've started this practice it is interesting to note that my rewriting workload has become almost nonexistent. In my last three novels the most I've done post-editorial is some line editing and the odd additional sentence here or there. I guess that makes my 'utter garbage' better than my 'doing my best'. And on that note I am off to have some really awful ideas and then write garbage.
